✦ The Archetype and the Polarized Response

Whenever a soul of high spiritual rank appears — like ʿĪsā (as), Amīr al-Mu’minīn ʿAlī (as), or the Rahbar — they act as a divine mirror, reflecting truth, justice, and moral authority.

But that mirror doesn’t flatter — it reveals. And for those unprepared or inwardly misaligned, that revelation can trigger extremes.

• Some idolize the figure, unable to separate the person from the divine truth they carry.

• Others reject and demonize them, because the light exposes what they are not ready to face within themselves.

This is not a new phenomenon — the Qur’an gives us the pattern:

• ʿĪsā (as): Some denied him outright. Others elevated him to divinity.

• Imam ʿAlī (as): Some turned against him (like the Khawārij), while others made divine claims about him (like the Ghulāt).

• The Prophet ﷺ: Some hated him while recognizing his truth. Others loved his personality but abandoned his message.

---

✦ Why This Happens

The issue is not with the figure — it’s with the lack of insight (baṣīrah) in the people.

• Those who lack inner vision cannot hold balance.

• They cling to emotionalism, politics, or tribal identity instead of spiritual perception.

• Divine archetypes demand internal clarity, but without purification, people fall into either blind adoration or resentful rejection.

---

✦ The Rahbar as Archetype Today

Today, we see the same archetypal reaction to the Rahbar.

• Some loathe him, shaped by media narratives or unresolved personal and political wounds.

• Others adore him excessively, out of groupthink, fear, or cultural loyalty — but without discernment.

In both cases, the person becomes a projection screen — not a point of reflection.

The lesson: This is not about the man. It’s about what he represents in the divine unfolding of time.

---

✦ The Call to True Insight

True spiritual maturity means you can:

• See the function, not obsess over the form.

• Hold reverence without blindness.

• Offer critique without rebellion.

• Understand that divine leadership is a test of your inner balance, not a personality contest.

---

✦ When Reverence Turns into Distortion: The Ghulāt and the ‘Alī-Allahīs

The danger of spiritual imbalance doesn’t only lie in rejection — sometimes it appears in the disguise of excessive love. When reverence loses its anchor in tawḥīd, it mutates into something dangerous: ghuluw.

❖ Who Were the Ghulāt?

The Ghulāt were historical sects who exaggerated the status of the Imams, especially Imam ʿAlī (as), far beyond the boundaries of truth.

Among them were the ‘Alī-Allahīs — those who claimed:

• That Imam ʿAlī (as) was Allah in human form,

• That he never died,

• That he had divine powers independent of Allah.

This is not devotion. This is spiritual distortion — a breakdown in the line between Creator and creation.

Even Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq (as) condemned these ideas:

“Whoever claims divinity for us is a liar. We are servants of Allah, glorified be He. Do not exaggerate as the Christians exaggerated about ʿĪsā ibn Maryam.”

❖ Waliyyullah vs. ‘Alī-Allahī

• The Waliyyullah is the friend of Allah — the one who walks in His light, who is elevated by obedience, not confused with the Divine.

• The ‘Alī-Allahī, by contrast, projects divinity onto the Imam — confusing light through a servant with the Source itself.

The Wali is a mirror to Allah’s light.
The Ghulāt stared so long into the mirror, they thought it was the sun.

---

✦ But Didn’t the Imams Live On?

Yes — and this is where subtlety matters.

• The Imams (as) are martyrs (shuhadā’), and in the Qur’an, the martyr is never dead:

“Do not say of those slain in the path of Allah that they are dead. They are alive, but you do not perceive.”
(2:154, 3:169)

• Their souls are living, and their light remains active.

• But they still lived, died, and were buried — just as the Prophet ﷺ was.

---

✦ What About the Raj‘ah?

The Raj‘ah — the return — is part of Twelver Shi‘i belief:

• Certain souls, including some Imams and enemies, will return before the Day of Judgment.

• This return is not because they never died, but because Allah’s justice is still unfolding.

It is a divinely sanctioned return, not a denial of death or humanity.

---

✦ When Light Is Misread

When people do not have clarity of heart, they confuse:

• Divine reflection with divinity,

• Sacred function with inherent godhood,

• Wilāyah with ulūhiyyah.

This is the root of ghuluw — not too much love, but love unmoored from tawḥīd.

---

✦ Real Love Is Always in Balance

The two extremes — of hatred and idolization — often stem from the same root:
a lack of true, rooted, spiritual love.

True love is not about obsession or possession.
It is about knowing someone’s essence, accepting their limits and roles, and loving them within the divine framework, not outside it.

❖ Real Love Can Say:

• “You are not God — and I still revere you.”

• “You made mistakes — and I still honor your truth.”

• “You shine — but your light is from the Source, not the source itself.”

That’s why love, when rooted in tawḥīd, never becomes ghuluw. It keeps the hierarchy of being intact — Creator above creation, no matter how luminous the creation becomes.

---

✦ Love Without Tawḥīd Isn’t Love — It’s Ego in Disguise

Most hatred, like most idolatry, is ego reacting to the mirror:

• Hatred is when the mirror reflects what we can’t bear.

• Idolatry is when we fall in love with the reflection and forget the Source.

• True love is when we see the reflection and bow only to the Light behind it.

---